The games that mean a little extra.
They built this league together. This is the one week a year they remember they also hate each other.
🏆 Bragging rights: Drew Tannenbaum (2-0)
Total opposites — Sterling's run-heavy, low-scoring, grind-it-out football. Logan's the pass-heavy, shootout guy. Even in Madden, these two can't agree on how football should be played.
🏆 Bragging rights: Sterling Valentine (2-0)
This rivalry is based on a young man who's been taken under an OG's wing and is still in his shadow, trying to become a man in the league.
🏆 Bragging rights: Tied (1-1)
You never know what's on the other side of a glory bole.
🏆 Bragging rights: Joey Trippeda (1-0)
Sponsored by Trulieve. Nobody's used a turn signal since 2019. As Luis put it: this rivalry needs to be immortalized.
🏆 Bragging rights: Tied (1-1)
The inaugural name on the wall. Somebody had to be first.
Career rivalry record across both meetings (2025 + 2026 Week 3).
| Manager | Rivalry Record | 2025 Rivalry Week | 2026 Rivalry Week |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drew Tannenbaum | 2-0 | Week 2 — Drew won, 201.42–161.48 | Week 3 — Drew won, 254.78–197.22 |
| Jason Azif | 0-2 | Week 2 — lost to Drew, 161.48–201.42 | Week 3 — lost to Drew, 197.22–254.78 |
| Sterling Valentine | 2-0 | Week 9 — Sterling won, 224.00–221.34 | Week 3 — Sterling won, 233.74–202.80 |
| Logan Hill | 0-2 | Week 9 — lost to Sterling, 221.34–224.00 | Week 3 — lost to Sterling, 202.80–233.74 |
| Tyler Hill | 1-1 | Week 1 — lost to Gio, 196.80–198.40 | Week 3 — Tyler won, 262.54–168.48 |
| Gio Miele | 1-1 | Week 1 — Gio won, 198.40–196.80 | Week 3 — lost to Tyler, 168.48–262.54 |
| Luis Torres | 1-1 | Week 4 — Luis won, 231.08–210.70 | Week 3 — lost to Evan, 142.86–232.40 |
| Evan Keyser | 1-1 | Week 4 — lost to Luis, 210.70–231.08 | Week 3 — Evan won, 232.40–142.86 |
| Peyton Vilardi | 0-1 | Did not play in 2025 (see note below) | Week 3 — lost to Joey, 188.90–224.70 |
| Joey Trippeda | 1-1 | Week 2, 2025 — lost to PantyDroppa (Alex Lawson) | Week 3 — Joey won, 224.70–188.90 |
Note: Joey's original rival was PantyDroppa (Alex Lawson), who has since been replaced by Peyton Vilardi for 2026.
FL/NY Gents